Circular Logic
Aimee Mann – Wise Up
Audio clip: Adobe Flash Player (version 9 or above) is required to play this audio clip. Download the latest version here. You also need to have JavaScript enabled in your browser.
This district never ceases to amaze me. The following scenario is now a reality:
District says to school: “You need to improve, so you must choose one of three options, option A, option B, or option C for running your school next year. Your choice is due today.”
The next day, school chooses option C.
The following day, District says to school: “We’re changing the rules. You may not choose option B. You may not choose option C. And if you want to choose option A, you’ll have to invent a time machine, because it’s too late now to choose that option.”
While the above scenario is a gross oversimplification of the situation many schools are finding themselves in nowadays, there is quite a grain of truth in it.
While the eternal optimist in me thinks that the above logical conundrum district policy finds itself in is the result of well-intentioned overzealousness (thus a rules correction is in order), it is nonetheless disheartening to try to work through with a policy that’s now fundamentally (and logically) broken.